Succession

Hey [RELEVANT_NEWS], Please Buy My Stuff!

Succession's Guide to Email Personalisation

By Keith Daly · 5 min read

Hey [RELEVANT_NEWS], Please Buy My Stuff!

Succession's Guide to Email Personalisation

Author

Keith Daly
November 15, 2026

Read time: 5 minutes

Welcome to the Succession newsletter where 2,000+ life science sales reps improve their skills in 5 minutes per week. If you’re getting value from these newsletters, we'd love it if you could forward it along to your sales colleagues. If you’re new here, subscribe below.

Succession Bio works with life science/biotech companies to help drive sales, licensing, and partnership opportunities.

We do this through market research to identify the right companies and people, craft scientifically credible messages, and then perform the outbound sales and marketing tactics on your behalf to facilitate meetings with the right people at the right companies.

Succession

  • Specializes in life sciences/biotech (it's all we do!)

  • Provides market research, messaging, and outbound sales/marketing services

  • Facilitates meetings and opportunities with the right people at the right companies for our clients

  • Sales training for teams of 10+ who want to find and close more deals with biotech and pharma

As AI continues to reshape the way outbound sales is done, we are presented with new theories on what drives the best results almost weekly now.

At Succession we now send over 20,000 emails each week so we are better equipped than most to theorise on how best to personalise your sales emails as we enter the final stretch of 2026.

Here are 3 important aspects to consider the next time you sit down and type “Hey saw you went to The University of Alabama too, PLEASE BUY MY STUFF!!”

The Obvious

Why should you personalise your emails? Of course it shows you’ve done your homework, and it can help separate you from a surprisingly large amount of lazy competition out there.

Personalisation is also an easy way to show how your solution could improve the day to day life of your prospects.

You could open your email, and importantly your subject line, with something relevant to that scientist’s or company’s work. It can be a great way to get people to open your email and softly introduce your product, instead of jumping straight into “We do X, Y and Z. PLEASE BUY MY STUFF!!”

But here is where AI is causing tension around how best to personalise sales outreach. One camp will say lazy AI personalisation is worse than no personalisation. Another will tell you to put an AI generated opener on top of a templated email for more control over your copy. And another will nail their flag to the mast for 100% personalisation.

Ultimately I am not sure any one side is completely right, and each rep and company will have to settle on what best reflects their overall vision and brand.

But here is what our data says, based on 630 campaign between January 2024 and March 2026:

  • Fully personalised (whole email written for one person): 2.17% reply rate, 0.53% positive reply rate, about 5.3 positive replies per 1,000 emails

  • Templates with extra merge fields: 1.34% reply rate, 0.29% positive reply rate, about 2.9 per 1,000

  • Plain templates (first name and company only): 1.94% reply rate, 0.52% positive reply rate, about 5.2 per 1,000

So make your own judgement, but here’s how I read it. Fully personalised emails get the most replies. On positive replies, though, they only edge out a plain template by about one extra positive reply per 10,000 emails. The real loser is the middle ground, with templates stuffed full of extra merge fields getting roughly half the positive replies of either of the other two. So the camp saying lazy personalisation is worse than none has a point. If you do go the 100% route, the key is to train and set up your AI properly so it actually generates high quality content and not just SLOP.

So if positive replies are almost a tie, why bother going fully personalised? This leads quite nicely to the next point.

Protect that Deliverability

This one is definitely slept on by a lot of teams, especially ones that aren’t familiar with the ongoing battle between marketers and spam filters.

Spam filters are built to spot the same email landing in multiple inboxes. So if you are sending the same email and just changing the first name and company name, your domain health could quickly find itself in trouble.

This is one interesting advantage of the 100% personalised approach. On top of the higher reply rates, it also makes your email more likely to land in the person’s primary inbox.

Deliverability is a huge topic and best saved for another newsletter, but definitely consider the above as you design your next outbound campaign.

Get Creative

So from what we have seen so far, it would seem the best way to personalise your outreach is to go all in on the 100% unique approach. But here’s where it gets interesting.

It’s time to get creative. It is now possible to build custom landing pages, videos and content tailored to each account and to run targeted ABM campaigns more easily than ever.

So instead of just slapping a logo on a PDF, I would put the time into building a system using Clay, Claude Code or a mix of the two to start building well packaged business cases to send to your leads as part of your outreach.

Take a hypothetical example. Say you’re selling to a mid-sized biotech with a Phase II oncology asset and a CMC team that’s been hiring fast. Instead of the standard email and attachment, they get a landing page that maps their pipeline to the problems you help solve, plus a two-minute video walking them through it. That’s a very different first impression to “We do X, Y and Z.”

Use this approach to assess companies’ pipelines and send them your most relevant content, tailored to what will most likely speak to their business.

So here’s where you can start. Pick your 10 best accounts and drop them into Claude Code along with details about your business and ICP. Ask it to find recent news on each one like funding rounds, trial readouts or key hires and see what you could turn into a landing page or short video for them.

Additionally feel free to speak with Succession for a quick chat on how we would design outbound for your company.

Check out our Webinar this Thursday 19/November

  1. Lead Generation: We’ll build target lists, write scientifically relevant messaging, and send messages on your behalf to book qualified sales meetings with biotech and pharma companies.

  2. Training for Teams: If you want to upskill your team around prospecting, driving to close, key account management, AI, or any other topic, we can put together a training plan specific to your organization’s needs.

  3. Strategy Call: Need more than training? Want help implementing and executing your sales strategy? In a 30-minute call, we will assess your company’s current situation and identify growth opportunities.